Ricotta Cheesecake
with Blueberry and Lemon
Share this Recipe
This recipe for Ricotta Cheesecake with Blueberry and Lemon is brought to you in collaboration with BC Egg, who have financially compensated me to develop it.
All opinions are my own.
Yes, a cheesecake can in fact be light and airy! Ricotta cheesecake is a delightful alternative to the heavier cream cheese-based New York style cheesecakes, but they can also be a bit plain. Fortunately, there's a wonderful in-between: cheesecake made with a combination light ricotta and a richer cream cheese (or mascarpone - more on that below).
The tangy, fruity flavours of blueberry and lemon work phenomenally with the comparatively light taste of a ricotta cheesecake, and other variations are definitely doable. There's no crust to make, and you don't need to bother with a hot water bath during baking, which means the whole recipe delightfully simple to put together.
Fun fact! Technically speaking, ricotta isn't cheese. It's a cheese by-product. Ricotta is what you can make with the leftovers after you've already made cheese. After making cheese from cream, many of the milk solids remain suspended in the leftover watery whey. This whey is treated with heat and (often but not always) acid, which coagulates the milk solids into little bits. Strain those bits out, and just like that, you've got ricotta. The name even gives us a hint into this process: ricotta means "recooked" in Italian.
Now, I'm going to back down a little on the 'ricotta isn't cheese' thing. We can call it a cheese by-product, but it's also totally accurate to call it a whey cheese. Whey cheeses like ricotta and mizithra are categorized separately from 'true' cheeses in the Codex Alimentarius, but 'cheese' is still right there in the name. If I'm being fair (or perhaps a bit of a fence-sitter) I would argue that ricotta is a cheese in the broadest sense of the word, but not in the narrower, better-defined sense.
Still with me? Good, because I'm about to make things a bit weirder. Despite all that stuff I just said about making ricotta from whey, the truth is that almost nobody does this any more. Leftover whey is a massive, inescapable issue in the cheese-making world. Despite this fact, commercial ricotta isn't generally made using this glut of leftover whey. Instead, ricotta is generally made by starting with milk treated with heat and acid. It's a wonderfully easy process, and one that I actually used in this recipe for maximum tastiness (more on this later). Because milk has all of its milk solids still present, using it to make ricotta will yield you more product than if you start with whey. Milk is also a bit easier to work with, and a little richer thanks to the small amount of milk fat present.
But technically (there's that word again), is it still ricotta if you start with milk? There are plenty of cheeses made by souring and heating milk. Quark, for example, also makes great cheesecakes. These aren't categorized as whey cheeses, but as acid-set cheeses. So is milk-made ricotta ACTUALLY ricotta? I mean, it definitely hasn't been recooked, so even the name is no longer accurate.
If you're wondering whey... er, sorry, WHY any of this matters, rest assured that it's more than a matter of semantics. Whey has very, very little fat in it. Consequently, ricotta has very, very little fat in it. (Milk-made ricotta has a bit more of course, but still much less than any cheese made from cream). It's soft, smooth, and light tasting, but it lacks the rich milk fat that you'd find in true cheeses. This means that you can make a wonderful cheesecake out of it with only a fraction of the fat (and calories) found in a conventional cheesecake.
Let me be abundantly clear - ricotta cheesecake is NOT identical to cheesecake made with heavy cream-based dairy products. Much like they whey cheeses themselves, ricotta cheesecakes stand apart in a group of their own. But there is a delightful hybrid zone between cheesecake types, and that's the area we're going to be exploring in this recipe.
Ricotta AND....
If you make a cheesecake using only ricotta, is it technically a cheesecake? Cheese-by-product-cake definitely doesn't have a very appealing ring to it. Whey-cheesecake sounds a bit better, but still decidedly off-kilter. Broadly-speaking-cheesecake? Oof.
Fortunately, we can avoid existential cheesecake identity crises altogether here, as this recipe also calls for either cream cheese or mascarpone, both of which are definitely actual cheeses.
Ricotta cheesecake made with ricotta alone is definitely a thing, and it can be very good. But cutting all that fat out of a dessert has consequences. Without much milk fat, a cheesecake will be a dryer, plainer tasting, and less creamy. This isn't inherently bad, but I wanted to develop a recipe that felt a bit more... decadent.
Now, there are some so-called ricotta cheesecakes floating around on the internet that are trying to pull a bait-and-switch on you. They call themselves ricotta cheesecake, then they go and use 2-3 times more cream cheese than actual ricotta. Seems a bit like cheating to me. Rest assured, ricotta is very much the star in this dessert - but you have a choice between two very delightful, very different supporting characters. I'll cover the ins and outs of using cream cheese vs. mascarpone in the Recipe Notes below, as they yield rather different cakes. If you have the chance, I'd encourage you to try making this cake both ways. Either way, you're going to end up with something very special.
Recipe Notes
Choosing (or Making!) Ricotta
If you have a 20 minutes to cook and few hours to wait , I whole-heartedly suggest you make your own ricotta. It's surprisingly easy, inexpensive, and it yields the tastiest ricotta cheesecake. I won't get into the details of how to make ricotta here, but I can recommend this guide from The Kitchn if you're new to the process. You can see my own efforts from a double-batch in the image below.
To make enough ricotta for this recipe, you'll need about 2 liters (1/2 gallon) of whole milk, a few lemons, and some kind of setup to allow you to drain the finished product. Because you want to heat but not boil the milk, many guides will tell you that you need a thermometer, but I don't think they're strictly necessary. You want to turn the heat off after the milk has gotten foamy and is just starting to roll/simmer a bit more aggressively. If you have an electric heating element, be sure to move the pot off of it right away.
If you're not interested in making your own ricotta, store-bought will do just fine - with a few very important caveats. When baking with store-bought ricotta, you want to check the ingredients for binding agents like xanthan gum. These binders help to hold together the ricotta on the shelf, but they don't play nicely when the ricotta is baked. Cheesecake made with binder-containing ricotta can turn into a weepy, crumbly, disappointing mess.
You can use a low-fat ricotta if you want, but because ricotta is already very low in fat, the low-fat versions really aren't only minimally different anyway.
It's also worth noting that most store-bought ricotta includes added salt. It's not usually all that much, but you may want to reduce or omit the salt called for in the cheesecake recipe in order to balance this out.
Homemade ricotta, made from whole milk.
At this stage, it has been very thoroughly drained.
Cream Cheese vs. Mascarpone
Two cheeses, both alike in dignity,
In fair Cheesecake, where we lay our scene...
With all apologies to Shakespeare, the schism between these two cheeses is perhaps a little over-wrought. As with other recipes, opinions about Old World vs. New World ingredients can get a bit testy. Whether you go with mascarpone or cream cheese, you're aiming to add flavour and richness to the ricotta, and to give the finished cake a more luxurious texture. Both cheeses work beautifully in this respect, albeit in different ways. I'm not going to concern myself too much with notions of authenticity - instead, let's just talk about what each cheese brings to this cheesecake.
Cream Cheese
Cream cheese has a unique and distinctively tangy taste that's front-and-center in New York style cheesecakes, and other American-style cheesecakes. This is a pro if that's the flavour you're after, and a con if you're looking for something more neutral. Cream cheese is difficult to blend entirely into cake batter, and will often leave behind small chunks.
Cream cheese is generally quite easy to find, and comparatively inexpensive, which is one of its biggest advantages. While cream cheese is fairly rich, it is lower in fat, carbohydrates, and calories than mascarpone.
Mascarpone
A rich and wonderfully smooth Italian cheese, mascarpone is much more neutral tasting than cream cheese, and so are cheesecakes made with it. It incorporates into the batter much more easily than cream cheese, and tends to yield a more uniform texture in the finished product. Cheesecake made with mascarpone lacks the distinctive tangy taste of cream cheese, which may or may not be what you're looking for. Mascarpone tends to yield a cheese cake that has a softer, cakey texture.
In North America, mascarpone cheese can be hard to find, and is generally much more expensive than cream cheese. Mascarpone is higher in fat, carbohydrates, and calories than cream cheese.
---
My taste-testers had decidedly mixed preferences for the two cakes. Fans of tangy cheesecake were generally happiest with the cream cheese version. Those who preferred a softer, more cake-like experience preferred the mascarpone version.
Long story short: if you want an Old World style cheesecake, go with mascarpone. If you want something closer to (but definitely not identical to) an American cheesecake, go with cream cheese. If you can't decide... make both.
Top: Mascarpone variation
Bottom: Cream cheese variation
No Hot Water Bath?!
Correct. No hot water bath. Unless you want one, that is.
Hot water baths help cheesecakes cook evenly, reducing the risk of cracking and the degree of browning. But in this case we actually want more browning, as it helps the cake develop a flavourful pseudo-crust. Cracking might be an issue, but there are a couple of points to consider here:
- You're going to cover this with blueberry sauce. Blueberry sauce hides all sins.
- You can, weirdly, control/disguise the cracks to a degree. Dragging a knife through the unbaked top to decorate creates blueberry-line-break-points that tend to corral any cracks. You can see this in the photo at the very bottom of the post.
- They're just cracks. Cracked cheesecake doesn't taste any different.
Now, you absolutely COULD use a hot water bath to make this cake. There's nothing stopping you. You would have to adjust your baking time, but if you've made cheesecakes in this fashion before it won't be any different than what you're already used to. The usual caveats about carefully wrapping the pan with tinfoil and avoiding leaks all still apply of course, so proceed with caution.
I personally wouldn't bother with the hot water bath for a crustless ricotta cheesecake, regardless of my ability to bury imperfections under sauces. I like the browned edges, the cakey texture, and the overall simplicity. However, if you were thinking about adding a crust to this recipe (see Variations below), then I'd consider making the adjustment. If you do try this with a hot water bath, I'd love to hear how it goes!
Variations
In this section I'm going to take a little space to talk about some potential variations that you can try out with this recipe. If you've jumped ahead to this section looking for information about using cream cheese vs. mascarpone, scroll back up a little to the notes to the previous sections.
Fruit Options
I adore blueberry and lemon, but there are plenty of fruit options you could try out with little difficulty. If you're working with fruits that, like blueberries, produces a fair bit of liquid when they cook, you can generally make a straight substitution. If you don't want to use lemon (or another citrus) juice, you can swap it out for water instead.
Sour cherries would be fantastic choice here. I tend to think they'd be best with the cream cheese variation, but that might just be a product of bias, given how often cherries show up on New York cheesecakes. Raspberries would also be excellent. If you have access to them, blackcurrants would be phenomenal and very distinctive, though you may need to sweeten them a bit more than some other fruits.
Want get super simple? Omit the fruit entirely! Cheesecake purists around the world will tell you that a cake needs to stand up on its own merits, and I truly do believe this base recipe does just that. However, if you do decide to make changes, don't underestimate the impact of the lemon. The juice adds acidity and some flavour, but the zest actually contributes some pretty big flavour notes. There's nothing wrong with dropping that component if it works for you, but do take into account the overall shift in flavour profile. Completely plain cheesecake can be, well, a bit plain.
Crust
Want to add a crust? As long as you've got some experience with cheesecake crust, then I say go for it! Any graham cracker, cookie, or nut-based crust would be lovely. You can use pretty much any recipe that you like, and I don't believe you're going to need to modify the cooking time all that much, though you may want to opt for a hot water bath cooking method instead (see Recipe Notes above for more on this subject). If you're looking for something that would play off of the blueberry and lemon in particular, I suggest trying a hazelnut crust. I haven't got one to recommend myself, but if you have one that you love, please let me know in the comments!
Keep in mind that any crust you add will change the nutritional profile of the finished dessert. Needless to say, if you use Graham crackers or any other wheat-based biscuit, the recipe will no longer be gluten-free.
Nutritional Summary
GOOD NEWS:
As cheesecakes go, this is surprisingly light, and low in sugar. I'm not going to call it health food... but I will admit to having had a slice for breakfast.
BAD NEWS:
Bearing in mind that it is, of course, dessert - not much! The saturated fat content is on the high side, which you'd expect given all the cheese - but overall, it's a pretty trim recipe. Note that mascarpone has more calories, fat, and carbohydrates than cream cheese, which will kick those numbers upwards somewhat!
TRIM IT DOWN:
Cream cheese will be leaner than mascarpone. While I don't recommend tweaking the base recipe too much the first time around, you could experiment with a higher ratio of ricotta to cream cheese once you've gotten comfortable baking this recipe too.
Ingredient & Pantry Pages
Categories
Ricotta Cheesecake with Blueberry and Lemon
Equipment
- 1 9 inch springform pan
- Stand or hand mixer
Ingredients
- 4 large eggs separated
- 15 oz ricotta drained (see note)
- 8 oz cream cheese or mascarpone (see note)
- 3/4 cup granulated sugar
- 1 tsp vanilla
- 2 tsp lemon zest
- 1 tsp lemon juice
- 1/4 tsp salt
Blueberry Topping
- 1 cup blueberries (~150 grams/5.3 oz)
- 1/4 cup lemon juice freshly squeezed
- 2 tbsp water
- 1/4 cup sugar (see note)
- 2 tsp tapioca starch (see note)
Instructions
Blueberry Topping
- Combine the blueberries, lemon juice, and sugar in a medium sauce pan over medium heat. Bring to a gentle boil, then reduce to a simmer. You may want to mash the berries slightly as they cook to release more juice.
- Whisk the tapioca starch with the water. Stir this mixture into the hot blueberry sauce, then set aside to cool.
Cheesecake
- Grease a 9-inch (23 cm) springform pan with butter. For added ease of removal, I like to line the bottom with a circle of parchment paper as well.
- Place a rack in the middle of your oven, then preheat to 325°F (163°C).
- In a clean stand mixer bowl (or large non-reactive bowl with a hand mixer), beat the egg whites until they are firm and holding their shape, but not forming stiff peaks. Remove the egg whites from the bowl and set them aside.
- (Optional) - For a smoother cake texture, blend the ricotta with the egg yolks before combining with the remaining cake ingredients.
- In the same mixing bowl, combine the remaining cake ingredients. Mix with a paddle mixer (or hand mixer beaters) until well-combined (don't worry too much about small pieces of cream cheese that won't mix in).
- Gently fold the whipped egg whites into the batter with a spatula. Pour the mixture into the greased springform and tap to level.
- Drizzle a few tablespoons of the blueberry sauce onto the top of the batter (try to use the more liquidy portion of the sauce for this). You can drag a small knife through the sauce for added decorative effect, if you like.
- Bake for 1 hour, or until browned at the edges and just barely set in the center. Turn off the heat and leave the cheesecake in the oven with the door closed for an additional 30 minutes. Remove the cake from the oven and cool on the counter for 10 minutes. Loosen the springform (run a knife around the outside if you're concerned about sticking). Allow the cake to cool completely, then chill in the fridge overnight.
- Top the chilled cheesecake with the blueberry sauce, or serve individual slices with sauce on the top or the side.
Notes
Nutrition
Let Them Eat (More) Cake!
Share this Recipe
Comments
This is the perfect spring dessert! The blueberry lemon combo is one of my favourites! I also really enjoy a light and airy cheesecake since I grew up with German cheesecake (made with quark) which are also less dense than a New York style one.
A friend of mine compared it to Hungarian cheesecake as well. It definitely has a wonderful Old World/European flavour when you use mascarpone, and I think quark would be very similar. I haven’t made this specific cheesecake with quark, but I’ve made others, and I love the results.
“Cheese-by-product-cake” – lmao. Thanks for the great article on ricotta, I really enjoyed learning more about it. And the blueberry sauce on this tasty cake was divine.
Hah, thanks Asha! Glad you enjoyed it.
No crust, no hot water bath and a lighter “cheesecake”–my kind of easy dessert! And that blueberry sauce was the perfect crowning touch!
I love that this cheesecake has no crust, so it’s gluten free. I also love that there’s no hot water bath required ( I totally agree that cracks don’t make the cheesecake taste different). Finally, I love that it’s a ricotta cheesecake, and the lemon and blueberry are a delicious flavor combo. Beautiful cheesecake!
another great recipe. using ricotta is actually more enjoyable and really light and fluffy. The lemon and blueberry sauce is the perfect pairing for this easy to make recipe!
I learned so much from this post- thank you! And I love ricotta cheesecake because of how light it tastes. Can’t wait to make this cause that blueberry sauce had me salivating (and it’s 5 AM!😂)
What a phenomenal article! Thank you. Next time I make cheesecake, I’m going to try this recipe!
Thanks Jeff! I hope you enjoy it!