These cookies are deliciously buttery, and just sweet enough (as all good shortbread should be). But they're also decidedly different, thanks to the chewy bits of whisky-soaked oats and currants.
Tea time is lovely and all, but these call for a wee dram of something a bit stronger.
Hello my lovely readers. It's that time of the year again - time for the annual Diversivore shortbread recipe!
2023 was... well, it was something. I'm not big on diarizing, but suffice it to say that the past 12 months have been a little much. I'm happy to be here doing what I do, and grateful that things haven't been worse of course, but it's always a little disappointing when life tosses a few extra hurdles your way.
Fortunately, there are things that makes the seemingly unending parade of a hassles a little easier to swallow. Like cookies. And whisky. And yes, cookies with whisky.
Perhaps you've already raced off to the recipe card below so that you can begin making these cookies. In which case... I guess you're not reading this. So... uh, for those of you who are still here, allow me to explain the raison d'être behind whisky shortbread.
A few years ago, I posted my variation on a delightful Scottish dessert called cranachan. Cranachan is beautifully layered with fruit and whipped cream, but one of its key features is easy to overlook at first glance: whisky-soaked steel-cut oats. Oats are in plenty of desserts of course, albeit more often in the flattened 'quick' form. But by soaking the coarser steel-cut oats in a whisky, we create a delightful punch of bold flavour, along with a pleasantly chewy texture. When I started dreaming up ideas for this year's shortbread variation, I returned to the idea with gusto. I toyed with the flavours for a while, wanting to add something fruity to the base. Eventually I landed on tiny, chewy currants (more on these below) - another classic ingredient common to baked goods in the British Isles. They brought their own jammy sweetness to the table, and provided a convenient way to soak in even more whisky.
I was thrilled with the results. The oats and currants add depth of flavour and provide a wonderful textural contrast to the crumbly, dry-yet-buttery shortbread. And, perhaps most importantly, they carry the rich flavour of the whisky throughout the dough. Alcohol added directly to dough can often end up getting somewhat lost in the finished product, but this method concentrates it into little 'punches' of flavour, keeping it at the forefront. The whisky flavour is prominent, yet well-balanced, and lacking any of the bite that one might associate with the drink itself. In essence, you get a cookie with grown-up flavours that still manages to please the wee ones (trust me). And yes, you can feed these to your kids without any concerns. Nobody's getting drunk on shortbread.
I hope you'll find some time to make cookies. For yourself, for your loved ones, even for strangers. It's a therapy that comes cheap, and does the world plenty of good. Admittedly, I had to push myself to get this recipe done - but I'm awfully glad I did. I'm happier now, sharing these with you. What more could I ask for?
I want to leave you with a couple of traditional lyrics that have been on my mind all through the development of these cookies. And until next time, here's to good will, good food and drink, and good company. Cheers to you, my friends.
Then stick to the Cratur1 the best thing in nature
For sinkin’ your sorrows and raisin’ your joys.
Oh Lord knows I wonder if lightning and thunder
Was made from the plunder of Poitín,2 my boys!
1. Creature - in this case, meaning whiskey or strong drink.
2. Also whiskey. More broadly, single-pot, generally
illicitly produced whiskey (or similarly distilled alcohol).
And there's a hand, my trusty fiere1!
and gie's a2 hand o' thine!
And we'll tak' a right gude-willie waught3,
for auld lang syne.
1. friend
2. give me
3. good-will draught
Recipe Notes
Currant Affairs
Blackcurrant ≠ dried currant.
Currant is a deeply frustrating word. The tiny little dried fruits used in these cookies (and indeed in any baked good that calls for 'currants') is not in any way related to the tart black, red, or white fresh fruits we commonly call currants.
The currants in these cookies are small dried true grapes (family Vitaceae). The variety of grape is called the Corinth grape - in North America they're often sold fresh as 'champagne grapes' (which is annoying, as they're not in any way used to make champagne). Over time and across translations, the word "Corinth" became currant in English.
Blackcurrants are small, tart fruits in the gooseberry family (Grossulariaceae), and are completely unrelated to grapes. The word 'currant' was borrowed from the familiar dried grapes, because heaven forbid we use a new word. Sigh.
If you've been operating under the idea that dried currants are blackcurrants, you are wrong - but you are certainly not alone. There's a lot of confusion over this idea, further amplified by the fact that both are small dark fruits, and both are rather popular in British cuisine.
I do have some good news though - you're not really going to have to worry about any of this when you shop for ingredients. Dried blackcurrants are basically a non-existent entity at any common commercial scale. If you're in a store and they sell bags of tiny dried fruits called currants, you can pretty much guarantee that they are the raisin type. If you're in America, you might find these fruits labelled as Zante currants. These are the currants you're looking for.
While you shouldn't have any trouble shopping for (Zante) currants, it is nonetheless worth pointing out that these little fruits taste like raisins, not blackcurrants. Please do not post a comment below complaining that your cookies had raisins in them.
Now I know there are plenty of anti-raisins-in-cookies people out there, but I do encourage you to give (Zante) currants an honest go. They are delightfully dark and sweet, with an intense jammy flavour. Their small size makes them much less texturally intrusive than larger raisins too. Plus, they soak up and compliment the whisky really nicely. And if anyone gives you side-eye and says "are there raisins in these?" you can just say "they're currants."
Whisk(e)y
Whiskey = the preferred spelling in Ireland and the USA, and for products produced in those countries.
Whisky = the preferred spelling everywhere else.
Can't talk about whisky shortbread without talking about whisky! I used a relatively inexpensive single-malt Scotch whisky to make these. When it comes to sipping, I'm a fan of many different whiskies, including smoky and peaty varieties - but when it comes to baking, I'd stick to smoother flavours.
You can definitely substitute another whisky (or whiskey) here too. Just bear in mind that the flavour is what matters here! If you have a smooth and rich Irish whiskey, rye whisky, bourbon, etc., that you particularly like, feel free to use it here.
What About the Alcohol?
The entire recipe calls for 8 tablespoons (~120 ml) of whisky. Even if all of the actual alcohol remained behind after cooking, that would mean that each cookie would have meagre 1/2 a teaspoon (2.5 ml) of whisky in it. Most whiskies are 40% ethanol (ethyl alcohol) by volume, meaning that there would be less than a quarter teaspoon (~1 ml, or 0.8 grams) of ethanol per cookie. In reality there will be less than this, as a portion of the ethanol will evaporate during the baking process. Exactly how much will evaporate is exceptionally difficult to say, but it will be some. But even if we assumed that all of the ethanol stayed behind and was absorbed as quickly as if it were consumed in a liquid form (which is definitely not the case), you would need to eat 17 cookies in rapid succession in order to consume the amount of ethanol found in one standard drink. That's over 2,600 calories of shortbread, for the record.
Biologically speaking, the quantity of ethanol in these cookies shouldn't be any cause for concern, even for children. Many foods produce small quantities of ethanol as they ripen or ferment, and our bodies are well-equipped to handle this from a very early age. Once again ignoring all evaporation during baking, one of these cookies (assuming a batch size of 48) would contain 1 ml (0.8 g) of pure ethanol. To compare, this is about as much ethanol as you'll find in an American-style hamburger bun (at 1.28 g ethanol/100g, per this study on Ethanol exposure in children).
All that being said, biology isn't always the only thing to take into account. I wouldn't make these cookies for someone who has struggled with alcohol addiction, for example. This has nothing to do with metabolism, and everything to do with psychology (and basic decency, in my opinion). Whisky shortbread tastes like whisky. That's great if you like whisky, but not so great if you've struggled with alcohol abuse. When in doubt, remember that I have a whole bunch of other shortbread recipes you can make.
Note: Nutritional Information is given for a single cookie (1/48 portion of the total recipe).
Nutritional values will vary depending on the size of the cookies you make!
Nutritional Summary
GOOD NEWS:
Shortbread is much less sugary than many cookies, so there are fewer calories and added carbohydrates than you might otherwise expect here. And hey, currants are fruit. Fruit is good.
BAD NEWS:
They're cookies, folks. They're not meant to be health food. Lots of delicious butter makes for lots of fat. Don't worry about it too much. Enjoy.
Ingredient & Pantry Pages
Categories
Whisky, Oat, & Currant Shortbread
Ingredients
Whisky Oats
- 3/4 cup steel cut oats
- 6 tbsp Scotch whisky
Soaked Currants
- 1/2 cup dried zante currants (see note)
- 2 tbsp Scotch whisky
- 1 tsp vanilla
Cookie Dough
- 4 cups all purpose flour (see note)
- 2 cups butter softened
- 1 cup white sugar
- 1/4 cup brown sugar (packed)
- 1/2 tsp salt
- whisky soaked oats (from above)
- whisky soaked currants (from above)
Instructions
Day 1 - Soaking the oats and currants
- Combine steel cut oats and 6 tbsps of whisky in a small, resealable container. Stir and seal the container tightly. Leave over night.
- Combine currants, 2 tbsps of whisky, and vanilla in a second small, resealable container. Stir and seal the container tightly. Leave over night.
Day 2 - Shortbread time!
- If you haven't already done so, take the butter from the fridge to let it soften.
- With a stand- or hand-mixer, thoroughly combine the soft butter, sugars, and salt. I prefer to use a paddle attachment for this.
- Add the soaked oats and currants to the mixture and thoroughly combine.
- With the mixer running, add the flour 1 cup at a time, pausing to allow it to incorporate in the butter mixture. Once all of the flour has been added and fully incorporated, stop mixing and set the dough aside.(Note: if desired, the dough can be refrigerated at this point and the cookies can be finished later).
- Preheat an oven to 350°F (175°C) and place a rack in the approximate center.
- While the oven is heating, shape small handfuls of dough into balls. See "Cookie Size" notes below for details.
- Gently flatten/shape the dough balls onto a baking sheet, making sure to space them out a bit to account for spread. You can line the pan if you want, but the quantity of butter in the dough generally makes the baked cookies very easy to remove from the bare tray.
- Place a baking sheet of cookies in the oven. Bake until the bottom edges are turning a light golden brown and the cookie centers are set. The actual time will vary depending on your oven, how cold your dough was, the size of the cookies, and your specific baking sheets. In my oven, 50 gram cookies took 20-22 minutes, while 30 gram cookies were done in 16-17 minutes.Remove the finished cookies from the oven and set aside to cool. Once cool enough to touch, transfer to wire rack or cool plate.
- Repeat the baking steps with all remaining dough.(Note: I like to use a second baking sheet to measure and flatten the next batch while the first batch cooks. This makes it less likely that you'll encounter problems with hot/cold spots in your oven.)
Notes
Nutrition
More Shortbread Recipes
Share this Recipe
Comments
Well I almost stopped reading after ‘no one’s getting drunk off of shortbread’ hahaha. But I’m glad I read on to learn all the current information about currants. I happen to be firmly in the ‘raisin lover’ category so I’m thrilled to have yet another option to annoy those around me with. An excellent bake Sean. Hope all is well.
This is my type of cookie! I have a hot cup of tea every afternoon and these are the perfect pairing!
I always enjoy a good shortbread cookie and this one is no exception. The combination of oats, currants and whiskey was unique and delicious. Would make these again.
The internet is missing dude recipes like these! My husband would be all over this! A whisky cookie! Dangerously yummy stuff you making here, Sean!
My husband loves shortbread and I love whiskey – so this is a match made in heaven for us! They were delicious.
Sean these shortbread are so friggin addicting! i don’t know whether I want to share these with my daughter or not. I think i need to make a double batch. one for myself strictly speaking.